DUI Refusal to Submit to Breathalyzer

Experienced DUI Defense in Scranton, Lackawanna County & Northeast Pennsylvania

Schedule A free consultation Call Now

If you refused to submit to a breathalyzer or blood test during a DUI stop in Pennsylvania, you are likely facing serious legal consequences – even if you were not ultimately convicted of drunk driving. Pennsylvania’s implied consent law means that simply refusing a chemical test triggers automatic penalties, and prosecutors can use your refusal against you in court.

At Shane Scanlon Law, we understand how the system works because Shane Scanlon helped build it. As the former District Attorney for Lackawanna County, Shane spent years prosecuting DUI cases. Now he uses that insider knowledge to defend people like you. If you refused a breathalyzer anywhere in Northeast Pennsylvania, call us today for a free, no-obligation consultation

Pennsylvania’s Implied Consent Law – What It Means for You

When you obtain a Pennsylvania driver’s license, you automatically agree to submit to chemical testing (breath, blood, or urine) if a law enforcement officer has reasonable grounds to believe you are driving under the influence. This is known as implied consent under 75 Pa. C.S. § 1547.

Refusing to submit to a blood draw or breathalyzer does not mean you avoid the DUI process. In fact, Pennsylvania law treats a refusal as a separate civil offense with its own independent penalties, on top of any criminal DUI charges that may be filed. In Lackawanna County and throughout Northeast Pennsylvania, officers typically request a blood draw rather than a breath test, so most refusal cases in this region involve a refusal of a blood draw specifically.

Call 1.833.658.9833 or submit the contact form below.

Name(Required)

In need of immediate
Legal representation?

Free No Obligation Phone Consultation

833.722.6566

Automatic Penalties for Refusal

A refusal triggers a mandatory license suspension by PennDOT, regardless of whether you are convicted of DUI:

  • First refusal: 12-month license suspension
  • Second or subsequent refusal: 18-month license suspension
  • If you have a prior DUI conviction: 18-month suspension

These suspensions run in addition to any suspension imposed as a result of a DUI conviction.

Can a Refusal Be Used Against You in Court?

Yes. Pennsylvania allows prosecutors to introduce evidence of your refusal to test at trial. A jury can be instructed that they may draw an adverse inference from your refusal, meaning they may conclude that you refused because you believed you were impaired. This is one of the most important reasons to have experienced legal counsel immediately after a DUI arrest.

However, a refusal is not automatic proof of guilt. Shane Scanlon knows how prosecutors build these cases and where the weaknesses are. Not every refusal is clear-cut, and there are meaningful legal defenses available.

DUI Refusal and the Highest BAC Tier

Under Pennsylvania DUI law, a refusal to submit to chemical testing is treated as a first-tier general impairment offense under 75 Pa. C.S. § 3802(a). This means that even without a BAC reading, you can be prosecuted and sentenced for DUI based on the refusal alone. Because no chemical test result exists, the prosecution builds its case on the officer’s observations, field sobriety test performance, and the fact of the refusal itself. First-tier penalties for a refusal-based DUI include:

  • First offense: up to 6 months probation, $300 fine, no mandatory jail time
  • Second offense: 5 days to 6 months in jail, $300 to $2,500 fine, 12-month license suspension
  • Third or subsequent offense: 10 days to 2 years in jail, $500 to $5,000 fine, 12-month license suspension

Aggravating factors, such as a minor in the vehicle or an accident causing injury, can significantly increase these penalties.

Can You Still Apply for ARD After a Refusal?

The Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD) program may still be available to first-time offenders even if you refused chemical testing, but it is not guaranteed. Each county DA’s office in Pennsylvania exercises discretion over who is admitted to ARD, and a refusal can make admission more difficult.

As a former District Attorney, Shane Scanlon has direct experience with how ARD decisions are made in Lackawanna County and throughout NEPA. He can evaluate your eligibility and advocate on your behalf for admission to ARD, which if successfully completed, can allow your charges to be dismissed and your record expunged.

Potential Defenses in a DUI Refusal Case

Every DUI refusal case is different, and the facts matter enormously. Shane Scanlon will carefully review the circumstances of your stop and arrest. Common defense strategies in blood draw and breathalyzer refusal cases include:

  • Unlawful traffic stop: if the officer lacked reasonable suspicion to stop your vehicle, the entire case may be subject to dismissal
  • Failure to properly advise of implied consent rights: police are required to read a specific DL-26 warning informing you of the consequences of refusal
  • Medical or physical inability to provide a sample: certain medical conditions may constitute a valid reason for inability to test
  • No actual refusal: ambiguous responses, language barriers, or confusion may not constitute a clear refusal under the law
  • Equipment or procedural issues: problems with breathalyzer calibration, officer training, or testing procedures
  • Challenging the adverse inference: legal arguments to limit or exclude refusal evidence at trial

Shane will explore every avenue to challenge the charges against you and minimize the consequences you face.

Why Choose Shane Scanlon Law?

Shane Scanlon is not just a defense attorney, he is the former District Attorney of Lackawanna County with over 20 years of courtroom experience. He has personally prosecuted DUI cases and now uses that knowledge exclusively to protect his clients.

  • Former Lackawanna County District Attorney
  • 20+ years of courtroom experience in Northeast Pennsylvania
  • Thousands of criminal cases handled from DUI to homicide
  • Dozens of jury trials taken to verdict
  • Deep knowledge of local courts, prosecutors, and procedures
  • Free, no-obligation consultation

When you are facing a DUI refusal charge, you need someone who knows exactly how the other side thinks. That is Shane Scanlon.

ShaneScanlon

Call Shane Scanlon Law Today – Your Free Consultation Awaits

If you or a loved one has refused a breathalyzer or blood test during a DUI stop in Pennsylvania, do not wait. The consequences begin immediately, and the sooner you have legal representation, the better your options. Call us today or submit the contact form below to schedule your free, no-obligation consultation.

Schedule A free consultation Call Now
How to Reach

Don’t settle for Second best

Schedule a free no obligation consultation with Shane today!

Call 1.833.722.6566 or submit the contact form below.
Name(Required)

Frequently Asked Questions